This explainer is based on a new report by Bruce Baker: “State Constitutions, Federal Statutes & Education Rights in New Jersey”(opens in new tab).
Every child in New Jersey has a right to an excellent public education.
In response to pressure from school boards, educators, and families, New Jersey has begun a major overhaul of the state’s school funding system.[1] The state’s current system is based on the School Funding Reform Act (SFRA) of 2008, using the law’s complex formula to determine how much state aid every New Jersey school district should receive. Public education advocates say the formula is outdated and underestimates what many districts need.[2]
As the state updates the SFRA, it must remember that school funding holds a special place in state policy. Of all the major services and programs the state provides, K-12 education is the only one explicitly protected by the state’s constitution. The state’s courts have ruled again and again that adequate school funding is a constitutional requirement. That means lawmakers cannot rewrite SFRA based on policy preferences alone. The new system must meet the requirements of New Jersey’s constitution.
This explainer answers questions about New Jersey’s constitutional requirement to adequately fund schools. It also outlines actions the state should take to ensure that all of its students receive the education the constitution guarantees them.
What is an “Adequately Funded” Education?
In broad terms, an “adequately funded” education is one where schools have the money they need to help students reach specific learning goals. Students have different needs, so some schools need more resources than others to reach those goals.
New Jersey, like all states, has set standards and outcome goals for its K-12 students. The New Jersey Student Learning Standards “provide clear and consistent learning goals across nine distinct content areas,” spelling out what students in every school should learn at each grade level.[3] As state and federal law requires, New Jersey gives annual statewide tests aligned with the standards to measure whether students meet them.[4]
A large and growing body of research shows that students have better learning outcomes in schools that receive more funding.[5] NJPP analysis also shows that the state’s standards have become more demanding in recent years, raising expectations for students.[6] To reach these higher goals, schools need enough, or “adequate,” funding.
In New Jersey, an adequately funded education is one where schools have the money students need to master the state’s learning standards. This means schools have enough well-trained teachers, administrators, and support staff to teach those standards, with the right materials, in buildings that support learning. All of these resources cost money. Without enough funding, students can’t reach the goals the state has set for them.
Federal, State, or Local: Which Government Guarantees the Right to an Adequately Funded Education?
A strong K-12 public school system brings major social and economic benefits to the whole country.[7] Yet, K-12 education in the United States is largely a state responsibility. The U.S. Constitution does not explicitly guarantee children a right to an education.[8] Every state constitution, including New Jersey’s, requires the state to provide schooling for its children.[9]
New Jersey’s constitution states:
The Legislature shall provide for the maintenance and support of a thorough and efficient system of free public schools for the instruction of all the children in the State between the ages of five and eighteen years.[10]
This language sets education apart from other public services. The state can choose, for example, whether to run a public transit system. The constitution gives it no such choice on schools: the state must educate its children.
As in other states, the governor and Legislature govern and fund New Jersey’s K-12 schools. They hand off the details of running the schools to the state Board of Education and Department of Education. Local school boards run individual school districts, but all of their decisions must follow state laws and rules.[11]
The state has the final responsibility to ensure that all of its children receive the education its constitution demands.
What Role Do the Courts Play in Defining Education Rights?
New Jersey’s constitution clearly requires a “thorough and efficient” education for all students.[12] But that language only matters if someone enforces it, and that job falls to the courts. Other states have similar language, but only some state courts have chosen to enforce it. New Jersey, to its credit, is one of those states.[13]I
Through decades of court cases, New Jersey’s Supreme Court has ruled that this language is “enforceable.” In other words, the courts can order the Legislature and governor to pass laws that create a “thorough and efficient system of free public schools.”[14]
The courts have also found that the “thorough and efficient” clause requires the state to provide an adequately funded education for all students. Every school needs enough money to give every student the chance to meet the state’s standards.[15] It should be noted that, as NJPP outlines in several recent reports, New Jersey’s actual funding of schools often falls short of this goal.[16] Still, even partial enforcement by the courts has pushed New Jersey to make a strong effort to fund its K-12 schools.[17]
What Were the Abbott Decisions, and How Do They Connect School Funding and Rights?
In 1981, 20 children attending schools in Camden, East Orange, Irvington, and Jersey City sued the state in the landmark case Abbott v. Burke. They argued that inadequate school funding violated their constitutional rights. The case eventually covered 31 urban districts that serve many children living in poverty. The New Jersey Supreme Court sided with the students. In a series of later rulings, known as the Abbott decisions, the court required the state to create a school funding system that protects students’ right to an adequate education.[18] Specifically, the court required the states to fund these districts at a base level “substantially equivalent” to wealthy suburban districts. The state also had to pay for the extra programs that students living in poverty need.
The Abbott decisions rest on a simple idea: the constitution requires that all children have an equal opportunity to reach common goals, such as the state’s learning standards. It is the state’s job to make sure schools have the resources to do that, including programs, services, buildings, and preschool. The court found that the Abbott districts, because of their high poverty rates, needed extra support to provide these programs and services. These districts could not raise enough money on their own, so the state should cover the costs.
In 2009, the court approved the Legislature’s plan to address these inequities: the School Funding Reform Act (SFRA) of 2008. SFRA applies to every district in the state, not only the 31 Abbott districts, including districts with lower poverty rates.
What Does “Thorough And Efficient” Mean for Different Students and Communities?
Money directly affects school quality and student outcomes, including test scores, graduation rates, college attendance, lifelong income, and even mortality and crime rates.[19]
All students should have an equal opportunity to attend an adequately funded school and achieve high educational goals. But not all students have the same needs. Schools that serve more students living in poverty, more multilingual learners, or more students with special education needs require more resources to give their students a fair chance to meet the state’s standards.[20]
New Jersey communities also differ in wealth, so they differ in how much money they can raise for their schools. Cities and towns with higher property values can raise the money their schools need with lower tax rates than places with lower property values. Districts with lower property values rely on state aid to help keep their school tax rates affordable while still fully funding their schools. At the same time, if the state does not require it, a town could choose to keep its tax rates low and underfund its schools.
A “thorough and efficient” school funding system accounts for these differences in student needs and in how much each district can raise through taxes. Yet, after decades of court rulings and new laws, New Jersey still has not reached its goal of placing every student in an adequately funded school. This failure violates the clear language of the “thorough and efficient” clause, and the state must fix it.
Why Don’t Schools Always Get the Funding They Need?
There are at least four reasons a school can fall short of the money it needs to meet state standards:
- Inadequate state aid. A district with low property values may tax its residents at high rates and still raise little money per student. Raising its tax rate even higher would put an unfair burden on taxpayers and still would not raise enough for an adequately funded education.SFRA is supposed to make up the difference with state aid that covers what a district needs but cannot raise on its own. But as earlier NJPP reports show, the SFRA formula is out of date, and tied to older, less rigorous standards.[21] As a result, state aid falls short, and the district’s students do not get an adequately funded education.
- Inadequate local revenues. SFRA sets a “local fair share” for each district: the amount the state believes a district can reasonably ask its residents to pay for schools through property taxes. The state calculates this amount using the district’s property values and residents’ incomes, which together measure how much a district can raise locally. A district’s state aid depends in large part on these measures. But the state does not require a district to raise its local fair share. If a district sets its tax rates too low — even if it has the ability to set them higher without an undue burden on its residents — it may not raise enough money to adequately educate its students. A district may also be unable to raise their full local fair share because of state limits on property tax increases.[22]
- Inequity within a district. A district may collect enough money from local, state, and federal sources to provide an adequate education for all of its students. But it may then divide that money among its schools and programs in ways that leave some students short. For example, a district may give each school the same amount per student. A school that serves more students with special education needs then cannot hire the extra staff those students need. The split may look “fair” on paper, but the students who need more resources aren’t getting them. Only some students, therefore, are receiving an adequately funded education.
- Funds diverted from district students. State laws require school districts to send some money — including local tax dollars — to private schools that enroll children who live in the district.[23] Private schools use this money, which would otherwise be provided by tuition or donations, to cover costs for items such as transportation or special education services. In some districts, these costs may grow large enough to deny public school students an adequately funded education.
Not all of these problems start with state policy. But in every case, the state is ultimately responsible for fixing them. Local school boards have no power to take away a child’s state constitutional right. If students do not receive an adequately funded education, the state must step in and make sure they do.
What Can State Leaders Do to Protect Students’ Right to an Adequately Funded Education?
When addressing these constitutional violations, the state has multiple options. The most important step is to fully fund SFRA and update it regularly to match current standards. New Jersey’s courts have ruled that SFRA is constitutional only if its funding targets are tied to the state’s student outcome goals.[24] To stay constitutional, SFRA needs regular, careful reviews that use modern methods and current data, rather than the arbitrary changes made in the past.[25]
But state aid is not the only reason schools come up short. SFRA’s “local fair share” reflects how much a district can raise locally, but districts do not have to raise it.[26] The state should amend SFRA to require districts to raise their full local fair share so local school boards cannot deny their communities’ children an adequately funded education.
The state can also use its authority to regulate how local school boards budget. These rules can limit their ability to divert funds and make sure they meet state standards for every child in the district. School boards can and should respond to what their communities want for their schools. But federal law requires some spending, such as special education services under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act. Beyond that spending, the state has full authority to direct those funds back to district schools to meet its constitutional duty.
Finally, parents, educators, taxpayers, and students have a part to play. Public education advocates should use public school finance sources, such as the School Finance Indicators Database. These tools show which districts are the most underfunded and how that underfunding shows up in test scores.[27] This information can be valuable when making a case for school funding reforms at the state and local levels.
Advocates should remind state legislators and local school boards of their duty to all of New Jersey’s children. Both are responsible for keeping the constitution’s promise. Voters should ask candidates for school board and state office hard questions: Do they understand the state’s constitutional duty to students, and will they uphold it?
End Notes
[1] Rosenberg, L. “There’s one huge thing that needs to change in N.J. schools, new education chief says.” NJ.com. Sep. 13, 2026.
[2] Borowski, N. “New Jersey seeks local guidance as it prepares to take state school funding formula ’down to the studs’.” The Philadelphia Inquirer. Oct. 6, 2026.
[3] New Jersey Department of Education. New Jersey Student Learning Standards (NJSLS). Accessed Nov. 7, 2026.
[4] New Jersey Department of Education. Welcome to the New Jersey Assessments Portal. Accessed Nov. 7, 2026.
[5] Jackson, C. K., and Mackevicius, C. L. “What Impacts Can We Expect from School Spending Policy? Evidence from Evaluations in the United States.” American Economic Journal: Applied Economics. vol. 16, no. 1. Jan. 2024. pp. 412–446.
[6] Baker, B.D. and Weber, M.A. New Jersey School Funding: The Higher the Goals, the Higher the Costs. New Jersey Policy Perspective. Feb. 2022.
[7] Jackson, C. K. “The Macroeconomic Returns to School Finance Reforms: Micro-Calibrated Predictions Meet Causal Evidence.” NBER Working Paper Series (Cambridge, Mass), Sep. 2026.
Mitra, D. The Social and Economic Benefits of Public Education. Education Law Center-PA, 2011.
[8] San Antonio Independent School District v. Rodriguez, 411 U.S. 1 (1973).
[9] Hunter, M. State Constitution Education Clause Language. Education Law Center. Accessed Nov. 7, 2026.
[10] New Jersey Legislature. NJ State Constitution, Art. VIII, § IV, para. 1. Accessed Nov. 7, 2026.
[11] Asher, K., Burns, J.J., Greitz, R.A., Jahn, C.A., Rebovich, Jr., K., Tanksley, Jr., C., Vrancik, M. Basic School Law. New Jersey School Boards Association. 2019, p. 3.
[12] New Jersey Legislature. NJ State Constitution, Art. VIII, § IV, para. 1. Accessed Nov. 7, 2026.
[13] Education Law Center. Abbott v. Burke Overview. Accessed Nov. 7, 2026. State courts in Louisiana, Alabama, Mississippi, Georgia and Florida have denied any legally enforceable right, even though Florida voters ratified new, stronger language regarding education rights in 1998 and 2002; see: Baker, B.D. Financing a High-Quality System of Free Public Schools for Florida’s Children. Dec. 2, 2025.
[14] Education Law Center. Abbott Decisions.Accessed Nov. 7, 2026.
[15] Education Law Center. The History of Abbott v. Burke. Accessed Nov. 7, 2026.
[16] Weber, M. A. Resetting School Funding for New Jersey’s Next Decade. New Jersey Policy Perspective. Oct. 2025; Baker, B.D. Estimating the Costs of an Adequate Education in New Jersey. New Jersey Policy Perspective. Oct. 2025; Baker, B.D. and Weber, M.A. Reforming School Funding in New Jersey: Equity For Taxpayers, Excellence For Students. New Jersey Policy Perspective. Sep. 2024.
[17] Baker, B.D., Di Carlo, M., and Weber, M.A. The Adequacy and Fairness of State School Finance Systems, 8th Edition. Albert Shanker Institute. Feb. 2026.
[18] Education Law Center. Abbott Decisions. Accessed Nov. 7, 2026.
[19] Baker, B. D., and Knight, D. Does Money Matter in Education?. Albert Shanker Institute. Jan. 2025.
[20] Baker, B. D., and Knight, D. Does Money Matter in Education?. Albert Shanker Institute. Jan. 2025.
[21] Baker, B.D., and Weber, M.A. Unlocking Academic Success: Revitalizing New Jersey’s School Funding Formula for Student Achievement. New Jersey Policy Perspective. Sep. 2023.
[22] Farrie, D. A Roadmap For Improving New Jersey’s School Funding Formula: Modifying The Property Tax Cap. Education Law Center. Oct. 2024.
[23] Weber, M.A. No Matter What You Call Them, Private School Vouchers Are Bad for New Jersey. New Jersey Policy Perspective. Apr. 2024.
[24] Abbott v. Burke, 199 N.J. 140 (2009).
[25] Baker, B.D., and Weber, M.A. Reforming School Funding in New Jersey: Equity For Taxpayers, Excellence For Students. New Jersey Policy Perspective. Sep. 2024.
[26] Weber, M.A. How Does New Jersey Fund Its Schools — And How Can We Make It Fairer? New Jersey Policy Perspective. Oct. 2025.
[27] Albert Shanker Institute. The School Finance Indicators Database. Accessed Nov. 7, 2026.